The book is a gripping account of Joe Simpson's survival, but the reader's enjoyment is marred by the discovery that Simon Yates did not write the sections attributed to him and by Simpson's problematic views.
This book is a jaw-dropping account of Joe Simpson’s survival in a dire situation. The narrative is compelling, but the experience is soured by the revelation that the sections from Simon Yates’s perspective were not actually written by Yates. This misrepresentation affects the reader's interpretation and enjoyment of the story. Additionally, Simpson's racist tendencies and his comments about female bodies further detract from the overall positive experience. Despite these issues, the book provides a heartening look at Simpson's recovery from PTSD through speaking engagements. The story is incredible, and while there is some climbing jargon, it does not detract from the overall narrative. The descent down the mountain is particularly exciting, and the book would have been even more enjoyable with a better understanding of the mountaineering terms used.
Quick quotes
This book is undoubtedly a jaw-dropping account of Joe Simpson’s survival in a situation most others would not have survived.
It leads to a completely different experience and interpretation of the reading material believing someone wrote that as opposed to knowing they did not.
It was sad to read about Simpson’s experiences during the filming process that impacted his mental health severely, uncovering the PTSD he had been living with for 17 years.