The reviewer praises Kory Stamper's book as a defense against linguistic pedantry, highlighting its celebration of English's messy evolution. The book is seen as a rebuke to grammar scolds, emphasizing language's adaptability and human influence.
Megan Garber's review of 'Word by Word' commends Kory Stamper's approach to language, criticizing the strict rules enforced by grammar scolds. The book is not just a memoir but also a history of English, showing how it thrives through experimentation and individual creativity. Garber appreciates Stamper's defense of language's natural evolution, pointing out that even esteemed figures like Jane Austen and Thomas Jefferson used 'incorrect' grammar, proving that language is dynamic and ever-changing.
Quick quotes
These are boom times for linguistic pedantry. Never before have there been more outlets for opinionated humans to commiserate about the absurdities of 'irregardless' or the impropriety of 'impact'-as-a-verb or the aggressive affront to civil society that is the existence of the word 'moist.
The vitriol is ironic — and, yes, I do mean ironic — and not merely because it puts the pendants in a precarious place, karmically.
Dictionaries are human-written documents, with all the subjectivity and fallibility that such production-side origins will entail.