Aiken's continuation feels more Gothic and includes shocking elements that deviate from Austen's style.
The reviewer felt that Joan Aiken's part of the novel didn't resemble a typical Jane Austen tale. Instead, it took a more Gothic turn with several shocking deaths in quick succession. The storyline seemed to diverge significantly from Austen's original style, which might not appeal to those looking for a continuation in the same vein. The reviewer found the departure from Austen's characteristic wit and social commentary to be a notable change.
Quick quotes
Joan Aiken's part did not seem like a Jane Austen tale.
It was very Gothic and contained three shocking deaths in a row.
The storyline seemed ...