They argue that the biography is somewhat lenient on Gladstone, suggesting he had more faults than the book acknowledges. The reviewer finds the narrative engaging but feels it could be more critical.
The reviewer appreciates the engaging narrative of Roy Jenkins' biography but feels that it is too kind to Gladstone. They believe that the book could have delved deeper into Gladstone's flaws and shortcomings, providing a more balanced view. While they acknowledge the book's strengths, such as its thorough research and engaging storytelling, they feel that a more critical perspective would have enriched the overall portrait of Gladstone.
Quick quotes
I think Roy Jenkins is too kind to Gladstone.
I think Gladstone had his faults and I think Roy is slightly too favourable towards him.
The biography is engaging but could benefit from a more critical perspective.