The expedition was a spectacular failure, but it's a compelling read. The lack of success doesn't diminish the narrative's power.
The reviewer acknowledges that Shackleton's expedition was a failure by conventional standards, even within the context of British heroic failure. They point out that the team never even set foot on the Antarctic mainland, which might disappoint some readers. However, the reviewer finds the narrative compelling and the account of the hardships faced by the crew to be gripping. The book is seen as a classic of mountain literature, and the reviewer appreciates the detailed descriptions and the sense of adventure that permeates the text. Despite the lack of success, the story is a testament to the spirit of exploration and the human capacity for endurance.
Quick quotes
Failed spectacularly, even within the British tradition of heroic failure.
At no point did they even set foot on the Antarctic mainland.
The narrative is compelling and the account of the hardships faced by the crew is gripping.