The novel is seen as a didactic construct prescribing sorrow and anger, but it effectively uses dystopian elements to explore societal issues. The narrative is compelling, though it may feel formulaic at times.
The Guardian's review positions America Pacifica as a dystopian novel that serves as a diagram for societal reflection. It highlights the novel's ability to evoke sorrow and anger through its depiction of a harsh, divided world. The reviewer acknowledges the book's strengths in storytelling and its use of familiar dystopian elements to create a compelling narrative. However, they also note that the novel can feel didactic and somewhat formulaic, which might detract from its originality. Overall, the review suggests that while the book is engaging, it doesn't break new ground in the dystopian genre.
Quick quotes
Dystopian novels such as America Pacifica are essentially diagrams for us to follow, didactic constructs prescribing sorrow and anger.
The concept of America Pacifica as an island refuge in a planet destroyed by global warming is brilliantly realized in all its brutality.
The narrative is compelling, though it may feel formulaic at times.