The book is criticized for not living up to its magical premise, being more of a soft paranormal romance with young adult angst.
The reviewer expresses disappointment that the book did not meet their expectations of a magical tale, finding it to be more of a typical paranormal romance with elements of young adult angst. They feel the premise of storing memories in books and removing them from a person's mind was not fully explored or executed well. Despite this, they acknowledge some engaging aspects but overall found it lacking.
Quick quotes
The book fails to deliver on its premise and is nothing but a soft paranormal romance at best.
Doused with some of the young adult angst, which Collins is ...
I was left feeling that the premise was not fully explored or executed well.