The Sign of Four

by Arthur Conan Doyle
The Sign of Four cover
Good Books rating 4.08
Buy online
Waterstones
Paperback • £7.50–£8.99
Amazon
Format/Price Check
Technical
  • ID: 10439
  • Added: 2026-01-25
  • Updated: 2026-02-02
  • Formats: 4
  • Reviews: 3
Reviews
Crime Book Girl · 2023-03-31
intriguing 4.00

The novel is praised for its intricate plot and historical context, making it a compelling read. The characters, particularly Holmes and Watson, are highlighted for their depth and development.

Crime Book Girl delves into the rich historical backdrop of the story, particularly the Indian Rebellion of 1857, which adds layers of complexity to the narrative. They appreciate how the author weaves together elements of adventure, mystery, and romance, creating a well-rounded and engaging story. The reviewer also notes the strong character development, especially of Holmes and Watson, which adds to the overall enjoyment of the book.

Quick quotes

    Holmes and Watson are soon deep into a dangerous and complex case involving stolen treasure, the Indian Rebellion of 1857, and a secret pact.

    The mystery itself had quite a few twists and turns and, as usual for a Holmes mystery, some bizarre twists.

    The case develops in an intriguing manner, with a back story that adds depth to the mystery.

Sammi Cox Blog · Sammi Cox · 2020-06-29
entertaining 4.50

The story is described as entertaining and melodramatic, with a fast-paced plot that keeps readers engaged. The climactic boat chase is particularly noted for its excitement.

Sammi Cox finds the novel to be a thrilling and fast-paced adventure, with a lot of action and drama. They particularly enjoy the epic night-time boat chase down the Thames, which adds a sense of urgency and excitement to the story. The reviewer also appreciates the melodramatic elements, which add to the overall entertainment value of the book. Cox notes that the short mystery is packed with a lot of content, making it a satisfying read.

Quick quotes

    Entertaining and melodramatic, this short mystery has a lot going on.

    Not to mention the epic night-time boat chase down The Thames.

    The story is full of drama and action.

The Guardian · 2012-06-26
unique 3.75

The mystery is commended for its twists and turns, although some aspects are considered bizarre. The reviewer appreciates the unique elements that set it apart from other Holmes mysteries.

The Guardian reviewer highlights the unique twists and turns in the mystery, which make it stand out among other Sherlock Holmes stories. They note that some of the elements might be considered bizarre, but these add to the overall intrigue and complexity of the plot. The reviewer also appreciates the well-crafted mystery and the engaging narrative that keeps readers on the edge of their seats. The historical context and the intricate plot are particularly praised.

Quick quotes

    The mystery itself had quite a few twists and turns and, as usual for a Holmes mystery, some bizarre twists.

    The case develops in an intriguing manner, with a back story that adds depth to the mystery.

    The story is full of drama and action.

Appears in Lists